home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- Xref: bloom-picayune.mit.edu rec.arts.sf.written:17187 rec.arts.sf.misc:3735 news.answers:4757
- Path: bloom-picayune.mit.edu!enterpoop.mit.edu!mojo.eng.umd.edu!darwin.sura.net!mlb.semi.harris.com!uflorida!purdue!haven.umd.edu!uunet!techbook!dant
- From: dant@techbook.com (Dan Tilque)
- Newsgroups: rec.arts.sf.written,rec.arts.sf.misc,news.answers
- Subject: rec.arts.sf.written FAQ
- Message-ID: <BzG90n.61s@techbook.com>
- Date: 18 Dec 92 09:57:56 GMT
- Expires: Fri, 18 Dec 1992 08:00:00 GMT
- Reply-To: dant@techbook.COM (Dan Tilque)
- Followup-To: rec.arts.sf.written
- Organization: Pseudopolis Yard
- Lines: 557
- Approved: news-answers-request@MIT.Edu
-
- Archive-name: sf-written-intro
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- This is the frequently asked questions (FAQ) list for rec.arts.sf.written.
- It is maintained by Dan Tilque (dant@techbook.COM). Improvements to
- this list are welcome.
-
-
- Table of Contents
-
- 0. Introduction
- 1. Story identification requests *
- 2. Spoilers
- 3. What books or stories are about X? *
- 4. What books have been written by author X?
- 5. List of the Hugo, Nebula, or World Fantasy Award winners
- 6. Science Fiction Archives
- 7. Does anyone want to talk about X?
- 8. Defining Science Fiction and/or Fantasy
- 9. Dividing line between Science Fiction and Fantasy
- 10. The SF-LOVERS Digest
- 11. Star Trek
- 12. Cyberpunk
- 13. Common abbreviations
- 14. Filking (Filksinging)
- 15. Kilgore Trout
- 16. Can the X beat the Y?
- 17. Clarke's Laws
- 18. HAL vs. IBM
- 19. Johnny Rico's ethnic group (Starship Troopers)
- 20. Science Fiction Book Club
- 21. The fourth book of Alexei Panshin's Anthony Villers series
- 22. PJF after Steven Brust's name
- 23. SF themes in music
- 24. Other frequent subjects
- 25. Oldest SF Authors *
- 26. William Ashbless
-
- * Significant modification to this entry
- ** New entry
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 0. Introduction
-
- Rec.arts.sf.written is a newsgroup devoted to discussions of written
- science fiction and fantasy. It is a high volume newsgroup and this
- article is intended to help reduce the number of unnecessary postings,
- thereby making it more useful and enjoyable to everyone.
-
- If you have not already done so, please read the articles in
- news.announce.newusers. They contain a great deal of useful
- information about network etiquette and convention.
-
- Please keep in mind these points:
-
- - Always remember that there is a live human being at the other
- end of the wires. In other words, please write your replies
- with the same courtesy you would use in talking to someone
- face-to-face.
-
- - Try to recognize humor and irony in postings. Tone of voice
- does not carry in ASCII print, and postings are often snapped
- off quickly, so that humorous intent may not be obvious. More
- destructive and vicious arguments have been caused by this one
- fact of net existence than any other. It will help if
- satiric/ironic/humorous comments are marked with the "smiley
- face," :-)
-
- - The net is a highly asynchronous medium. It can take several
- days for an article to make it to all sites. It is also quite
- common for followups to messages to reach a site before the
- original.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 1. Story identification requests
-
- "Does anyone know this story?" <plot summary follows>
-
- When making this kind of request, ask that all responses be e-mailed
- back to you. One way to encourage e-mail responses is to set the
- followup-to line to poster (i.e. Followup-To: poster). After having
- found out what it is, then post the correct answer to the net.
-
- If you know the answer but are unable to send a message to the requester,
- wait a few days. It's likely that someone else will post the correct
- answer, thus sparing you the effort.
-
- Do not post messages like "I want to know, too" to the net. E-mail the
- person who asked the question and request that they send you any
- information they get by e-mail. Only if you cannot reach the person by
- e-mail *and* no one has posted about the request after several days
- should you post.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 2. Spoilers
-
- Any message which reveals significant details of the plot of a book
- should be flagged with "SPOILER" in its subject line (preferably) or at
- least in the body of the message. Be considerate to other readers,
- don't ruin the surprises.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 3. "What books or stories are about X?"
-
- When making these kind of requests, ask that all replies be e-mailed to
- you and that you will summarize (set the Followup-to to poster to
- encourage e-mail response). Note that a summary is not just
- concatenating all the replies together and posting the resulting file.
- Take the time to strip headers, combine duplicate information, and
- write a short summary.
-
- Also note that at least two subjects, Arthurian and Robin Hood books,
- have FAQs posted to rec.arts.books and news.answers.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 4. "What books have been written by author X?" "What books are in
- series Y?"
-
- A number of bibliographies have been compiled and posted to the net by
- John Wenn. These bibliographies also contain info on which books are
- in a series or in the same universe. The most up-to-date bibliographies
- are availiable via ftp from world.std.com (192.74.137.5) [user
- anonymous, any password], directory pub/jwenn.
-
- They are also in the sf archives (see entry 6. Science Fiction
- Archives below). In the archives, the bibliographies are in directory
- pub/sfl/authorlists. Warning: the versions of the bibliographies at
- eddie.mit.edu may not be the most recent. The archives at Rutgers are
- kept up to date.
-
- File names are generally LastName.Firstname (e.g. Niven.Larry). Case
- *does* count.
-
- Requests for more bibliographies may be made to John at
- jwenn@world.std.com.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 5. List of the Hugo, Nebula, or World Fantasy Award winners
-
- Lists of award winners are in the Science Fiction archives on
- gandalf.rutgers.edu (see entry 6. Science Fiction Archives below).
- The lists are in directory pub/sfl with these file names:
-
- hugos.txt
- nebulas.txt
- world-fantasy-awards.txt
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 6. Science Fiction Archives
-
- The archives are availiable via FTP from either of
-
- gandalf.rutgers.edu (128.6.7.26)
- eddie.mit.edu
-
- Please contact these machines only during off hours, Eastern time zone,
- U.S.
-
- For BITNET people, and those without access to FTP, the archives are
- availiable via e-mail. Send mail to BITFTP@PUCC.BITNET, with the
- following in the message body:
-
- FTP gandalf.rutgers.edu
- USER anonymous
- CD <dirname>
- DIR
- GET <filename>
- GET <filename-2>
-
- The DIR command will return a list of all available files. The GET
- command will retrieve the files themselves (and multiple GET's per mail
- message are prefered).
-
-
- For European readers, you may want to access the archives at the Lysator
- Computer Club, Linkoping University, Sweden. It's e-mail address is
- ftp.lysator.liu.se (130.236.254.1). The administrator is Mats Ohrman
- (email: matoh@sssab.se). The bibliographies are in directory
- /pub/sf-texts.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 7. "Does anyone want to talk about X?"
-
- If nobody seems to be discussing what you want to talk about, post a
- (polite) message opening the discussion. Don't just say, "Does anyone
- want to talk about X" or "I really like X" however; try to have
- something interesting to say about the topic to get discussion going.
-
- Don't be angry or upset if no one responds. It may be that X is just a
- personal taste of your own, or quite obscure. Or it may be that X was
- discussed to death a few weeks ago, *just* before you came into the
- group. (If this is the case, you'll probably know, though, because
- some rude fool will probably flame you for "Bringing that up
- *AGAIN*!!!" Ignore them.)
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 8. Defining Science Fiction and/or Fantasy
-
- Many people have attempted to define them and probably the best answer
- was given by Damon Knight: "Science Fiction is what I point at when I
- say Science Fiction." Please do not discuss this topic unless you feel
- you have a truly novel definition.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 9. Dividing line between Science Fiction and Fantasy
-
- Many people have also attempted to pinpoint this and had no better
- success. Virtually every answer you give will fail to clearly indicate
- which category a large number of books belong to.
-
- Again, please don't discuss this topic unless you feel you have a truly
- novel answer.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 10. The SF-LOVERS Digest
-
- The SF-LOVERS Digest is a service for those who cannot read the
- rec.arts.sf newsgroups directly. It is a compilation of the articles
- posted to sf.misc, sf.announce, sf.fandom, sf.movies, sf.tv, sf.written
- and sf.reviews which is sent out periodically via e-mail. The
- moderator, Saul Jaffe, does a certain amount of editing when compiling
- the Digest. Duplicate information is eliminated and the articles are
- organized by topic. Also, most meta-discussions are not included in
- the Digest.
-
- To subscribe, unsubscribe, report problems, etc., send e-mail to
- SF-LOVERS-REQUEST@RUTGERS.EDU. To post articles to the various
- newsgroups use the following addresses:
-
- Topic Address
- ----- -------
-
- Written SF sf-lovers-written@rutgers.edu
- Sf on Television sf-lovers-tv@rutgers.edu
- Sf Films sf-lovers-movies@rutgers.edu
- General discussions that don't
- fit specifically in the other
- topic headings sf-lovers-misc@rutgers.edu
-
- Due to the high volume of mail, it's quite likely that administrative
- type messages sent to the wrong address will be ignored.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 11. Star Trek
-
- There is a hierarchy of newsgroups for Star Trek, rec.arts.startrek.*.
- If you have access to netnews, use it for discussions about any Star
- Trek subject (old series, new series, movies, novels, etc.). If you
- are absolutely sure you cannot access the startrek newsgroup, and you
- *must* post to sf.written, include the phrase "Star Trek" in the
- subject line.
-
- Do not post flames about people violating this guideline. Use e-mail
- to request they follow it. It's likely that this person is reading
- rec.arts.sf-lovers via the SF-LOVERS Digest and has no access to
- netnews or rec.arts.startrek. If so, that person will not see your
- flame because discussions of what's appropriate in the newsgroup are
- not included in the SF-LOVERS digest.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 12. Cyberpunk
-
- Cyberpunk is a subgenre of SF which (usually) combines high technology
- ("cyber") with an alienated, often criminal, subculture ("punk"). Some
- people consider cyberpunk to be a Literary Movement; others consider it
- a marketing gimmick. Arguing about which it is is pointless and not
- encouraged in this newsgroup. Probably the best definition parallels
- the one for Science Fiction (see 8. Defining Science Fiction and/or
- Fantasy above).
-
- There is a news group called alt.cyberpunk which is the best place to
- discuss cyberpunk. A comprehensive list of cyberpunk works can be
- gotten by sending e-mail to John Wichers at wichers@husc4.harvard.edu.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 13. Common abbreviations
-
- BTW -- "By the way"
- FTL -- "Faster than light"
- FYI -- "For your information"
- IMAO -- "In my arrogant opinion"
- IMHO -- "In my humble (honest) opinion"
- ISBN -- "International Standard Book Number"
- ROTF -- "Rolling on the floor"
- ROFL -- "Rolling on the floor, laughing"
- RPG -- "Role playing games", like D&D (Dungeons and Dragons)
- RSN -- "Real Soon Now" (== within the next decade or two)
- wrt -- "with respect to"
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 14. Filking (Filksinging)
-
- Filking, or filksinging, is SF/Fantasy fan folk music. The term
- derives from a typo in the word "folksinging" made in a program for a
- convention many years ago. Filksongs are often parodies of popular
- tunes or folk songs.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 15. Kilgore Trout
-
- Kilgore Trout is a fictitious SF author that appears in several books
- by Kurt Vonnegut. VENUS ON THE HALF-SHELL by Kilgore Trout was written
- by Philip Jose Farmer.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 16. "Can the X beat the Y?" where X and Y are mighty ships or alien
- races from different space opera books/movies/series.
-
- These kind of discussions are fairly pointless. Please keep them off
- the net.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 17. Clarke's Laws
-
- (This entry was written by Mark Brader.)
-
- Clarke's Law, later Clarke's First Law, can be found in the essay
- "Hazards of Prophecy: The Failure of Imagination", in the collection
- "Profiles of the Future", 1962, revised 1973, Harper & Row, paperback
- by Popular Library, ISBN 0-445-04061-0. It reads:
-
- # [1] When a distinguished but elderly scientist
- # states that something is possible, he is almost
- # certainly right. When he states that something
- # is impossible, he is very probably wrong.
-
- Note that the adverbs in the two sentences are different. Clarke continues:
-
- # Perhaps the adjective "elderly" requires definition. In physics,
- # mathematics, and astronautics it means over thirty; in the other
- # disciplines, senile decay is sometimes postponed to the forties.
- # There are, of course, glorious exceptions; but as every researcher
- # just out of college knows, scientists of over fifty are good for
- # nothing but board meetings, and should at all costs be kept out
- # of the laboratory!
-
- Isaac Asimov added a further comment with Asimov's Corollary to Clarke's
- Law, which he expounded in an essay logically titled "Asimov's Corollary".
- This appeared in the February 1977 issue of F&SF, and can be found in the
- collection "Quasar, Quasar, Burning Bright", 1978, Doubleday; no ISBN on
- my copy. Asimov's Corollary reads:
-
- % [1AC] When, however, the lay public rallies round an
- % idea that is denounced by distinguished but elderly
- % scientists and supports that idea with great fervor
- % and emotion -- the distinguished but elderly
- % scientists are then, after all, probably right.
-
-
- So much for Clarke's First Law. A few pages later on, in the final
- paragraph of the same essay, Clarke writes:
-
- # [2] But the only way of discovering the limits of the
- # possible is to venture a little way past them into
- # the impossible.
-
- To this he attaches a footnote:
-
- # The French edition of [presumably, the first edition of] this
- # book rather surprised me by calling this Clarke's Second Law.
- # (See page [number] for the First, which is now rather well-
- # known.) I accept the label, and have also formulated a Third:
- #
- # [3] Any sufficiently advanced technology is
- # indistinguishable from magic.
- #
- # As three laws were good enough for Newton, I have modestly
- # decided to stop there.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 18. HAL vs. IBM
-
- There is a relationship between HAL (the computer in 2001: A Space
- Odyssey) and IBM. If you add 1 to each letter in HAL you get IBM.
-
- According to Clarke, this relationship is entirely accidental. In
- fact, he claims that if he had been aware of it, he would have chosen a
- different name for his computer.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 19. Johnny Rico's ethnic group (Starship Troopers)
-
- What ethnic group does Johnny Rico, the protagonist in Heinlein's
- STARSHIP TROOPERS, belong to?
-
- (The following answer is from a posting by Eric Raymond.)
-
- From page 205 of the 1968 Berkeley edition (end of Chapter XIII):
-
- I said, "There ought to be one named _Magsaysay_."
- Bennie said, "What?"
- "Ramon Magsaysay," I explained. "Great man, great soldier -- probably
- be chief of psychological warfare if he was alive today. "Didn't you
- study any history?"
- "Well," admitted Bennie, "I learned that Simo'n Bolivar built the
- Pyramids, licked the Armada, and made the first trip to the Moon."
- "You left out marrying Cleopatra," I said.
- "Oh, that. Yup. Well, I guess every country has its own version of
- history."
- "I'm sure of it." I added something to myself and Bennie said, "What
- did you say?"
- "Sorry, Bernardo. Just an old saying in my own language. I suppose
- you could translate it, more or less, as `Home is where the heart is.'"
- "But what language was it?"
- "Tagalog. My native language."
- "Don't they talk Standard English where you come from?"
- "Oh, certainly. For business and school and so forth. We just talk
- the old speech around home a little. Traditions, you know."
- "Yeah, I know. My folks chatter in Espan~ol the same way. But where
- do you--" The speaker started playing "Meadowland"; Bennie broke into
- a grin. "Got a date with a ship! Watch yourself, fellow! See you."
-
- There is no room at all left for misinterpretation. Johnny Rico is a
- Filipino; Tagalog is a Philippine language, Ramon Magsaysay was a hero
- of the Philippine resistance, and many Filipinos have Spanish names.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 20. Science Fiction Book Club
-
- About once a year someone asks about the SFBC and the resulting
- discussion inevitably goes like this:
-
- A: I love it. I get hard cover books for about half the bookstore
- price. Plus they have these omnibus editions of various series so
- you can pick up several books in one volume. The binding may not be
- up to regular hardcover standards, but it's still better than
- paperback.
-
- B: Yeah, but I keep losing the monthly cards and end up buying or having
- to send back books that I don't want.
-
- C: You should do like I did. I called them up and got on the
- "Preferred Member Plan". On this plan I only get books when I send
- back the card.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 21. The fourth book of Alexei Panshin's Anthony Villers series
-
- Three books were published in the Anthony Villers series: STAR WELL,
- THE THURB REVOLUTION, and MASQUE WORLD. A fourth book was promised at
- the end of the third book and was to be titled, THE UNIVERSAL
- PANTOGRAPH. It was never published.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 22. PJF after Steven Brust's name
-
- The letters PJF are appended to Steven Brust's name in some of his
- books. What do they mean?
-
- PJF = Pre-Joycean Fellowship
-
- The name is modelled on that of an artist's group named the
- Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood. A number of writers have appended it
- including Brust, Emma Bull, Will Shetterly, Jane Yolen, Pamela Dean and
- Neil Gaiman (this is not an exhaustive list). Many, but not all of
- them are members of Minneapolis Fantasy Writer's Group, the
- Scribblies.
-
- In the words of Pamela Dean, here is roughly what the PJF is trying to
- do:
-
- "... we are trying to undo the separation of the so-called popular
- values and traits in literature (which probably include straight-
- forward narration) and the so-called literary values and traits
- (which probably include stream-of-consciousness writing). We don't
- always succeed; we don't always try; we don't feel that writers
- doing other things are evil. But we are trying to reunite, in our
- work, the popular and the literary. Every one of us has a different
- definition of those terms and a different notion of how what we are
- trying to do should be accomplished."
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 23. SF themes in music
-
- A list of songs which have science fictional themes is maintained by
- Rich Kulawiec. This list is posted to news.answers periodically. If
- you can not find it there, e-mail Rich at rsk@gynko.circ.upenn.edu.
- Alternate e-mail addresses for Rich are rsk@ecn.purdue.edu or
- pur-ee!rsk.
-
-
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 24. Other frequent subjects
-
- Some subjects have generated long and acrimonious arguments (flamewars)
- in this group. Please think twice before posting anything on these
- subjects.
-
- 1. Robert A. Heinlein's attitudes towards women especially as
- reflected in his female characters.
- 2. Orson Scott Card's attitudes towards homosexuality.
-
- Other subjects, while not generating flames, have been discussed
- numerous times in this group. Please consider carefully before
- starting dicussions on these topics.
-
- 1. The nature of time travel.
- 2. Asking everyone what the first sf they ever read was.
- 3. Casting your favorite book as a movie.
-
-
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 25. Oldest SF Authors
-
- Based on Tuck's ENCYCLOPEDIA OF SF AND FANTASY, the oldest SF writers are:
-
- Frank Belknap Long, 27 APR 1903
- L. Sprague De Camp, 27 NOV 1907
- Jack Williamson, 29 APR 1908
- Andre Norton, 1912
- A. E. van Vogt, 26 APR 1912
- R. A. Lafferty, 7 NOV 1914
- Lester Del Ray, 2 JUN 1915
- Jack Vance, 28 AUG 1916
- Arthur C. Clarke, 16 DEC 1917
- Frederick Pohl, 26 NOV 1919
- Sam Moskowitz, 30 JUN 1920
- Ray Bradbury, 22 AUG 1920
- Kurt Vonnegut, 11 NOV 1922
-
-
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------
- 26. William Ashbless
-
- Who is William Ashbless? Both Tim Powers (THE ANUBIS GATES) and James
- Blaylock (THE DIGGING LEVIATHON) have him in their books. Is this the
- same character?
-
- William Ashbless was a penname that Powers and Blaylock used to publish
- cowritten poetry in college. When they both needed a name for a poet
- character in their books, they independently used the same name. After
- this had been pointed out to them by their editor, they got together
- and added details to make it look it was the same guy.
-